Macallan As We Get It Bottled 1970's Independent Bottling

Macallan 18 Year Old Sherry Oak

I've tasted Macallan 18 year old sherry oak many times and this ain't it. So what is it? Well, I might conservatively call it attractively colored golden sputum masquerading as a fine scotch. Buyer beware: Avoid the 50ml "Macallan 18" at all costs. The nose smells like Bushmills' Irish whisky (which I happen to hate due to its lack of...

Score 61/100

Macallan Edition No.3

For the composition of this 3rd Edition, whisky maker Bob Delgarno collaborated with the well-known Master Perfumer Roja Dove, who had previously helped Macallan with the development of their aroma kit. This is a blend of six cask types in which the aroma will most likely be very important. The nose is wonderfully sweet, but also a bit delicate....

Score 86/100

Macallan Select Oak

I have had the pleasure of meeting Bob Dalgarno, the man responsible for crafting these Macallan whiskies and I have to tell you he knows his stuff. The painstaking procedure he goes to ensure consistency of color, flavor and taste is mind boggling. Macallan whiskies have no added color which makes it even more impressive. But what I like most...

Score 84/100

Macallan 12 Year Old Sherry Oak

Nose is wonderful, with sweet dark cherry, vanilla, and sherry wine. The palate is a letdown though. I get a bit of chocolate and raspberry. But it's not that pronounced and the flavors are somewhat weak. It's very smooth and drinkable though. Just, boring. Needs more. The finish however is fantastic. Long and spicy, with a drying oak. The...

Score 85/100